YourCT.com header image 2

Irony Alet: Big Brother Really Is Watching You


by turfgrrl


April 2nd, 2007 · 5 Comments

With the recent talk about security cameras at Calf Pasture Beach in Norwalk, I think it’s interesting to note that in Britain, which has deployed over 4.2 million CCTV cameras, according the Evening Standard, one for every 14 people in the country, there are studies that show that the average person is recorded on camera 300 times a day. Bringing Britain to that awkward point where fiction has become reality. And no greater irony in a map displaying the position of all those CCTV cameras surrounding the apartment where Orwell had lived.

From the Evening Standard:

On the wall outside his former residence - flat number 27B - where Orwell lived until his death in 1950, an historical plaque commemorates the anti-authoritarian author. And within 200 yards of the flat, there are 32 CCTV cameras, scanning every move.
Orwell’s view of the tree-filled gardens outside the flat is under 24-hour surveillance from two cameras perched on traffic lights.
The flat’s rear windows are constantly viewed from two more security cameras outside a conference centre in Canonbury Place.
In a lane, just off the square, close to Orwell’s favourite pub, the Compton Arms, a camera at the rear of a car dealership records every person entering or leaving the pub.

Map

Within a 200-yard radius of the flat, there are another 28 CCTV cameras, together with hundreds of private, remote-controlled security cameras used to scrutinise visitors to homes, shops and offices.

The message is reminiscent of a 1949 poster to mark the launch of Orwell’s 1984: ‘Big Brother is Watching You’.
In the Shriji grocery store in Canonbury Place, three cameras focus on every person in the shop. Owner Minesh Amin explained: ‘They are for our security and safety. Without them, people would steal from the shop. Although this is a nice area, there are always bad people who cause trouble by stealing.’

Three doors away, in the dry-cleaning shop run by Malik Zafar, are another two CCTV cameras.

‘I need to know who is coming into my shop,’ explained Mr Zafar, who spent £400 on his security system.

This week, the Royal Academy of Engineering (RAE) produced a report highlighting the astonishing numbers of CCTV cameras in the country and warned how such ‘Big Brother tactics’ could eventually put lives at risk.

The RAE report warned any security system was ‘vulnerable to abuse, including bribery of staff and computer hackers gaining access to it’. One of the report’s authors, Professor Nigel Gilbert, claimed the numbers of CCTV cameras now being used is so vast that further installations should be stopped until the need for them is proven.

One fear is a nationwide standard for CCTV cameras which would make it possible for all information gathered by individual cameras to be shared - and accessed by anyone with the means to do so.

The RAE report follows a warning by the Government’s Information Commissioner Richard Thomas that excessive use of CCTV and other information-gathering was ‘creating a climate of suspicion’.

source: Evening Standard, George Orwell, Big Brother is watching your house, March 31, 2007

Tags: Current affairs

5 Responses so far “Irony Alet: Big Brother Really Is Watching You”



  • 1 anonymous // Apr 2, 2007 at 8:04 pm

    Ironic indeed.

  • 2 anonymous // Apr 2, 2007 at 8:54 pm

    I like the protection of the cameras. If you are not breaking the law it should not bother you either.

  • 3 SteVe // Apr 3, 2007 at 2:22 am

    Cameras do not provide protection, they merely provide a record of an incident to help solve a crime. I’m guessing you have no problem with the police dropping by to search your house or your car? I mean, you’re not breaking the law, right?

    I don’t find private security cameras as onerous as those controlled by the government. Typically the information isn’t retained for very long & it isn’t transmitted anywhere. I would be concerned if they become networked or too readily available. Considering the large number of cameras operated by the government in the UK, they are well on their way to Orwell’s nightmare.

  • 4 the sono patrol // Apr 3, 2007 at 7:41 pm

    oh I have to weigh in on this one, I disagree with .Camera’s do provide protection and if we had them on in So Norwalk over the weekend it would of proved a valuable tool.We lived in a police state not knowing what was going on while our children played openly on the street with bikes, roller blades and 2 wheel scooters.The kids Stopped once in a while to talk to the police officers in thier cars waiting to make a armed arrest of a felon. Yes they did thier job but where everyone knew why they were there, did anyone think of simply telling the public parents in particular to have our kids wear flak jackets like the officers were wearing. Did our boys in blue think about the unarmed children playing around these stake outs,,

    Undercover? marked police cruisers with thier lights on for hours sitting around locations protecting us , looking for someone we all knew, could of asked if we saw him that would be community involvement.Then to read they took him in by drawing a weapons on him, just like they would of on our own Norwalk streets while our children played was distressing.

    They did a great job catching him and yes camera’s would be great because now that is over with try and find a cruiser on the same streets for more that a passing moment they were here for at least 3 full days 72 hours , crime hasn’t stopped in So Norwalk just the police presence, a camera could log how many times some areas actually get a pass by during a shift and help the commanders adjust their own patrols in the areas that need it the most.

    Give these guys the tools they need, its not the street officers that are to be doubted they are the best, its the $100,000 dollar job that concerns me and who is the most qualified.maybe the officer who actually caught this guy should be given the job, sounds like he earned it.

  • 5 the sono patrol // Apr 5, 2007 at 11:11 am

    just as I thought crime has not stopped, look at the Advocate’s police blotter for today wes the 5th, details two grug busts with ammunition where 17 and 16 year olds were caught, this paper is showing when where and who is committing crime most important to people who live in these areas..ciurt news only gives you a slight picture of what goes on every day,,my hat is off to the Advocate for telling us what we need to know about crime in Norwalk.