Posted on 12 February 2010.
Other states have them. Cameras atop traffic lights that automatically snap a photo of cars that run red lights. They are, to put it simply, controversial. The chief arguments for them go along these lines. Police Departments don’t have the manpower to enforce every traffic law, motorists know it, so they drive recklessly. The chief argument against them is that they violate some vague civil liberties and are money makers for governments.
Neither position really covers the issue in a fair manner. Like most things, the truth lies somewhere in the middle.
In Connecticut, no municipality is allowed to use them. The question before the legislature is decide on whether to allow them. Today, Mayor John DeStefano, Jr. and NHPD Assistant Chief KenGillespie will join the Connecticut Conference of Municipalities (CCM),members of the Connecticut General Assembly, Yale-New Haven Hospital andthe CT Livable Streets Campaignto announce support for the legislation, at a press conference in New Haven.
In March of last year, S.B. 149 made it out of the Transportation Committee, only to get stalled out in the much and mire of the endless budget debates. That bill featured the magnanimous gesture of a 50/50 revenue split with municipalities. I’d almost bet that somehow the burden of installation and maintenance fell 100% to the municipality.
The New Haven Independent reports the ACLU position:
The ACLU said it has not changed its position on the cameras, spokesman Patrick Doyle said. It still violates people’s privacy and due process rights, Doyle argued.
He criticized the impersonal nature of the camera-ticket strategy.
“When you get pulled over [by a police officer], there is interaction with a person,” he said. “The policeman will ask you what’s going on. That’s part of due process.”
The CT Livable Streets project proposes legislation here and gathers facts and presentations about the issue here.
Meanwhile the issue of just where does revenue go from traffic violations in Connecticut is itself mired in controversy. Good governance pacticies suggest that No local government should retain traffic fines. The money collected in local courts should be transferred to the state and returned via a local aid formula based on population. Yet what happens once money goes to the state? The municipalities in Fairfield County know the answer, it doesn’t come back here.
Governor Rell last year proposed adding cameras to record speeders on I-95. You can tell she doesn’t often travel I-95 in Fairfield County, but I digress. Her idea then was to split the revenues between the state and the camera operators. The legislature wisely shot it down.
Moving violation ticket fines go to the state. The municipality collects only $10 out of each ticket. If the State managed to actually reinvest ticket fines into road safety improvements, like funding new traffic signals and improving safety for pedestrians maybe the revenue split would make sense. But instead the money seems to go into the endless bottom of the general fund.
Automating ticket enforcement of moving violations is not a bad idea. Bu the money it generates should not go to private companies and should not go for anything but capital expenditures towards improving road safety. Without that focus, it would just be another unfunded piece of legislation not based in reality.
Recent Comments
Mickey Mosque ()- sonoresident: Just read a parent was arrested last week in Darien for going into Whole Foods with 2 kids in the...
- Barnstorm: My friends were right. There is an immediate need for a sarcasm font. Consider your chain yanked.
- BLARNEY RESURRECTED: BRAVO
- Barnstorm: OK. You win. Let’s not have the 51 Park Community Center be built. Let those would-be terrorists...
- BLARNEY DON'T NEED NO STEENKEN SUPER HERO: It seems that even when I was away Barnstorm abused everyone on this...
- turfgrrl: Can we bring this back to civility please?
Bad Weekend for Connecticut Residents ()- Antonia Walke: Your blog is true, I have facebook recommend to my friends, and support you.
Norwalk Inn Saves Historic Landmark ()- Red Remover: Hello thanx for the posting, I was looking for your Facebook page so I could like it. Will you guys be...
Fox News Is Grumpy 24/7? ()- BLARNEY THE IMPALER: YOU’RE A FUNNY GUY PS I read your letter in the Hour. Barnstorm The good news is, if you...
- Barnstorm: Could you cite specific examples of their “slant” or are you, as usual, just regurgitating...
- BLARNEY: Can you imagine if the only places we could get our news was from MSNBC aka MSOBAMANBC NY TIMES NEWS WEEK....
- Courtney Dahlin: Dude, I know you aren’t the kind of person that truly cares to become called dude, but dude!...
Chapter 11 For Politicians? ()- BEWARE BLARNEY'S STONES: Actually I have been held upside down by the knees to kiss the “Blarney Stone”...
- OLD TIMER: “BLARNEY” is the proper name for a place in Ireland, and a famous 1446 castle there, said to...
Double Standard In BOE Contract Negotiations? ()- OLD TIMER: Today’s HOUR has a front page story about the arbitration panel resolving the school...
Looking For A Job Today? ()- David Marcus: Speaking of supermarkets…what’ s going on with the new one they’re building in...
McMahon Win Says What Exactly About Connecticut Republicans? ()- TO CHANGE THE SUBJECT BLARNEY: Looks like the Oyster Festival may dodge the bullet. The hurricane...
- just asking: Right or left…extremism on any flank is dangerous. Not name calling; just calling attention to...
- BLARNEY IN THE KNOW: HITLER = The oooold Hitler name calling thingy fits right in with the old racist calling...
- Braemar: Hitler was a National Socialist = NAZI take over everything, then have power over all the people. take...
- just asking: Hitler won elections also…feeding on patriotism, national pride, religion, and disdain for the...
Urban Outfitters To Open In Greenwich ()- Enlightened: More importantly, Fairway Market is coming to Stamford soon! Now that’s a big deal!
- Just Me: I went to the GAP awhile ago to buy some shirts for a family member. I don’t know what group they...
Bank Robbery Monday Afternoon ()- OLD TIMER: When New York City was in similar trouble, Rudy Guliani got the police to focus on “quality of...
- Shootouts Continue: Two shoot outs occured saturday evening and early sunday morning. The first shoot out occured...
- OLD TIMER: Don’t think he was a hospital patient who escaped. He apparently has a history of abberant...
- Lunatic Terrifies Hopsital Neighbors.: just asking if anyone has any info on the emotoionally disturbed peerson...
- Lunatic Terrifies Hopsital Neighbors.: just asking if anyone has any info on the emotoionally disturbed peerson...
Guest View: Public Employee Pensions Need Legislative Action ()- F: Why aren’t there articles about cutting welfare, food stamps & the like? Where are the articles about...
Ghosts of World War II’s Past ()- Kenny Howse: What a fantastic idea! I do a bit of photoshopping myself and may try some of this technique!
New Book On Parenting Hits Shelves ()